Hey Jordan!
Hope all is well at Windward. I've used the following for three students:
Vanities (the cheerleader scene)
The Children's Hour (Peggy, Evelyn, Mary - I usually cut Rosalie unless you want 4)
Words Words Words (David Ives)
The Marriage Proposal (Chekhov)
Almost Maine (the scene with Villian)
The Philadelphia (David Ives)
Proof (Hal, Claire and Catherine)
Reasons to be Happy (Carly, Steph and Greg)
Ballerinas (Don Nigro)
Best wishes!