I hear ya! In 2007/2008 I was at a private school with about the same enrollment and started the Theatre program. We did the opposite of what you're doing - started with a spring musical and added a fall play a few years later.
Our 1st musical was OZ! by Tim Kelly, available at Pioneer Drama. The story is the same and the songs incredibly catchy!
The perfect resource for us was MTI's Jr musicals which are scaled down versions of large musicals. For about $600 you get the student books, director's book, & music tracks. They have many other resources available.
I would highly recommend HONK! Dear Edwina, Seussical - none is these require extensive sets. HONK takes place in a farm w/a pond, Edwina takes place in a front yard. Dear Edwina is really adorable and often overlooked. Keep in mind that you can do almost any musical you want - you just have to be creative with sets. I used many two-sided sets that opened up.
Starting from scratch can be scary. I'd be happy to visit with you via email, text or phone. cosand48@gmail.com
I'd love to hear what show you settle on. Good luck!
------------------------------
Connie Sandoz
Waxahachie, TX
Retired Theatre Director
Henderson, NV
Original Message:
Sent: 10-11-2016 14:32
From: David Sturdevant
Subject: Looking for simple, scaled-down Musical for small high school
Hi everyone,
I'm in my second year at a small private high school (130 students) where I've been rebuilding the theatre program. Last year, we produced Fools to great success with a simple set and lighting. This year, I'm producing 12 Angry Jurors in the fall and am looking for an accessible, easy-to-produce musical for the Spring. I don't think we're ready for much elaborate choreography or large choral numbers, so I'm looking for a show that still feels big but doesn't require large resources or technical means to pull off. We'll also be relying on recorded tracks or simple accompaniment for the music. I'm looking very seriously at Working (2012), Godspell (perhaps Jr. version) or The Spitfire Grill. Any insight into those shows or other suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks!
David Sturdevant
Middleburg, VA