Hey there Jane!
I'll start by saying I have not produced either of these with high school students, however,
Moby Dick has been on my radar for years. I was planning to do it this year, but then COVID put a stop to it. I will say that as much as I love it, I find the song "Primitive" to be quite problematic. I have a friend who worked on the original US production in Florida, and he knows one of the guys who wrote it and said it may be worth talking to them (through MTI) about a way to cut it or alter it to make it work. The cultural appropriation of the song is staggering.
As far as
Spitfire Grill, I worked on it in college and agree with Holly - the harmonies are tough and there really isn't room for expanding the cast other than adding a few unnamed patrons in the grill. I want to do this one soon as well, but will probably have to double cast most of the show (which I hate doing) just to make sure I have enough roles for the kids. Also - the cast album is on Amazon and is free to listen to there, and it can also be found on YouTube. The show is gorgeous but you need some STRONG female singers - Percy has quite the anthem in the 2nd act and Shelby sings a lot of tight harmonies. Joe can also be tough, it's a higher tenor role.
One last thing :) If you do it with a live band, you NEED the cello. It is SO moving and really helps with the music.
I love both of the shows, so if you need anything - please let me know.
------------------------------
Derek T. Pickens, MFA
Theatre Teacher
Charleston County School of the Arts
North Charleston, SC
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 01-27-2021 09:10
From: Jane Dewey
Subject: Anyone produced the following musicals?
Hi Theatre Minds! We are narrowing down our search for musicals for the spring. Has anyone had experience producing either "Moby Dick! The Musical" or "The Spitfire Grill" with high school students? These are two that I'm only know getting to know. Any/all insight is welcome! Thank you in advance!
------------------------------
Jane Dewey
Director of Arts Education
Danville Independent Schools
Danville, KY
jane.dewey@danville.kyschools.us
------------------------------