Hi Jennifer,
You may want to check out a couple radio plays we did to much success. War of the Worlds: The Panic Broadcast by Jon Jory and Vintage Hitchcock: A Live Radio Play by Joe Landry. Both are a lot of fun and have somewhat flexible casting. Both also require actors to perform foley sound live on stage which is a great addition to the show and a great skill for the actors to learn. Playscripts (where I found these shows) has a number of radio plays worth checking out.
Happy hunting and good luck!
------------------------------
Jillian Lietzau
Lutheran High School
CO
------------------------------