I am in a similar position, and I know it can be hard to find good plays for 20 Middle School actors, challenging for them but also appropriate for them. My students help select the plays, resulting in us typically producing comedies. You didn't mention if you were looking for "full-length" plays or not, but these are all 90 minute + plays. Here are a few of the student and audience favorites:
You Can't Take It With You by Moss Hart and George S. Kaufman - the classic comedy, perfect for all ages; might have to make a lot of kids government agents to get to 20.
Once in a Lifetime by Moss Hart and George S. Kaufman - lesser known but still funny, about the transition from silent to talkie pictures; tons of roles, but you can double.
The King Stag by Carlo Gozzi - commedia del'arte works for 18th century theatre buffs and 21st century MS students; had to cast some females in male parts, but it just added to the fun.
Great Caesar’s Ghost by Craig Sodaro - I remember this mostly for some great acting performances, but I think it is a pretty strong script too.
The Mouse That Roared by Christopher Sergel - some alums still quote their lines from this script, which I consider a good sign.
Fair Exchange by Shirley McNichols - a kind of Freaky Friday plot, and MS actors seem to love it when adults and kids switch bodies.
Chateau La Roach by Lauren Wilson - one of the funniest plays we've done, in the style of the television series Fawlty Towers.
Promedy by Wade Bradford - MS kids love playing high school students; because it's a small school, we can't do big musicals, but this also allowed us to feature a few strong singers performing to karyoke tracks (the original script calls for lip syncing).
A Knight in My Locker by John Foster & Christopher Burruto - time travel, comedy, and romance; MS kids loved it.
Spy School by Don Zolidis - 50s/60s spy movies go to high school; some juicy comedy roles that can be played to the hilt
------------------------------
Jeff Westbrook
Downers Grove IL
Original Message:
Sent: 01-20-2016 09:20
From: Andrea Haeussler
Subject: Desperatly looking for Middle School Play
Hi everyone! I ahve been reading tons of plays for Middle School and nothing convinces me.
I need suggestions! No musicals, cast of about 20 kids. Thank you!!
------------------------------
Andrea Haeussler
Drama Teacher and Theatre Manager
Colegio Maya
VIENNA VA
------------------------------