I definitely think Peter & the Starcatcher is expandable for a cast of 22 -- and figuring out creative ways to expand it could be an awesome artistic challenge for you and the cast.
Because you mentioned that your school and theatre program are so new, it might be helpful to think about your goals for not just this show, but future shows. If you want to do large-cast plays & musicals down the road, casting more students this year can be an investment in the future of your program. By giving them this opportunity now, you're building their skills, making it likely that you'll have a larger, more experienced pool of students auditioning for future shows.
That said, my advice would always be to listen to your gut and make whatever choice works best for you and your particular group. Best of luck with the production!
------------------------------
Elizabeth Berg
Drama Teacher
Ashland Middle School
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 01-12-2018 02:45
From: Arden Thomas
Subject: Peter and the Starcatcher - is 22 actors way too many?
I'd really like to just cast the 12 actors as scripted, but 22 kids have come out for the play. Since this is only the 4th show of our school (we were just founded last year) we wanted to celebrate and encourage everyone who enrolled by casting them all. But as I get closer to auditions next week, I'm desperately wishing I was only going to cast 12.
Has anyone done it with more than 12? I see comments on a thread from last year that advised sticking to the 12.
Thanks!
------------------------------
Arden Thomas
Teaching Artist, Theater
Sequoyah High School
Pasadena CA
------------------------------