While I do agree with you, we did the JR. version of Shrek last spring, and our Shrek was not a strong singer at all. Decent rhythm but unpredictable pitch. What he did have was an overpowering personality that completely carried the role and won over the audience, even when he was off on his songs - in fact, his 'weak' singing became an endearing aspect of his character.
And he didn't do the accent either - he just created his own Shrek that brought the house down. You'll have purists that will say he "wasn't like the movie," but for me, that's kind of the point!
We are still new in our community, and there's no choir and no encouragement toward singing, so starting to do musicals was kind of a risk. Maybe once we have a deeper roster of strong singers, my standards will shift upward, but for now, we overwhelmingly embrace energy and commitment over vocal brilliance. Weak actors with strong voices can anchor the ensemble, and don't have to be cast as leads. (No matter what their parents try to convince you.)
------------------------------
Josh Kauffman
Teacher
Winfield AL
Original Message:
Sent: 12-12-2016 13:58
From: Kelly Thomas
Subject: Shrek Auditions
Singing for boys is difficult. Have boys who are doing Pinocchio use their falsetto. The three blind mice sing in harmony need to be good singers. The knights sing in 4 part harmony, again you need your good singers. Have a Shrek who can blow the house away. It is a demanding tenor role. Overall, a great show and fun time for all who were involved. Break a leg
Kelly M. Thomas
Department of Theatre
Dr. Ralph H. Poteet High School
3300 Poteet Drive
Mesquite, Texas 75150
972-882-5300
Kthomas@mesquiteisd.org