Hi Joseph,
I am a theater teacher in Brooklyn at a school that is predominantly Black and Hispanic. I think it's great that you are exposing your students to this show and they love it. You're right; we do need more exposure to positive immigrant stories and this musical certainly is that.
I know you are seeking feedback specifically from people who have done the show and I have not, but (as you say) I do see the one difference here for you would be that your school is in Boston and you do have students of color in your school. I can't find the context of Lin Manuel Miranda's quote, but I would interpret it to mean that if a predominantly white school in Iowa wanted to work on this show, he'd love it because that school might have kids who would otherwise have no opportunity to get a glimpse into other cultures.
Given that my school is in a large, multi-ethnic city, I would not produce this show, and if I had to produce it, I would not produce this show with white students in the lead/speaking roles.
I hope you don't mind my response since, again, I know you requested advice from people who have done the show, but since we both work in urban schools, I thought my note might be relevant in a different way.
------------------------------
Jennifer DeRosa
Theater Teacher
Brooklyn NY
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 04-24-2019 09:26
From: Joseph Gels
Subject: In The Heights with race blind casting?
I teach at a Boston Public School that is about 50% White 28% Asian 12%Hispanic 8%Black and then the rest is mixed race non-hispanic.
I would like to do In The Heights next year for musical for a variety of reasons. Leading of which is that I feel like the world needs positive immigrant stories in the world right now, additionally the hype that will come with the movie and a lot of students at the school saw a nearby semi-professional production last year.
When I mention the idea of doing it to some of my students in the theatre company, I am getting a lot of fear reactions (they don't think it's fear but it definitely is) at the idea that we would need to do some race blind casting in the show (they know I'm not dumb enough to do anything like brown face, don't worry) and that people are going to get offended.
Has anyone done In The Heights at their school facing a similar situation? I know of schools with 95% white populations doing it. and to paraphrase Lin Manuel about those instances "I love the idea of a bunch of kids in Iowa having to track down Dominican flags and actually learn something about someone else's experiences" but clearly my school is a bit more complicated.
WOuld love any feedback from people who have done the show in similar situations to mine
------------------------------
Joseph Gels
Theatre Teacher
Boston Latin School
Boston MA
------------------------------