I cut my Ismene in
Antigone for both persistent absence from rehearsal and failure to learn her lines. I gave her several clear warnings about the issues, which she acknowledged. When nothing changed, I took her aside privately and told her that since nothing had changed, I needed her to return her script and withdraw from the production. Because of the way everything had proceeded, she gave me no argument. She clearly wasn't happy, but she understood that this was the way it had to go; she turned over her script and left the rehearsal. I then promoted one of my more promising female chorus members to the role of Ismene, and brought in a replacement for the chorus part, figuring that someone who had already been rehearsing the show could step into a principal part late in the game more successfully than a complete newcomer.
You seem to have reason to make a change, and the responses on this board give you clear precedent from your colleagues.
As to the tech rehearsal issue, I had a similar experience when one of my Gemini in
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum approached me just before we began our final dress rehearsal to tell me that she could only stay for Act I because she needed to attend her best friend's Sweet 16 party. I told her that generally no one was allowed to miss a dress rehearsal, especially for a purely social reason and most especially with no more advance notice than this. She seemed upset, but walked off without an argument, and Act I proceeded. I thought her lack of response indicated acquiescence, but when we started Act II, she was gone. Perhaps she thought herself irreplaceable, especially since I was lucky enough to have an actual set of identical twins to play the Gemini. But I simply pulled a chorus member aside (as we had enlarged the complement of courtesans beyond the named ones, in order to increase participation) and gave her the part. The next night, my original actress showed up, furious to find someone else in her costume, but I stuck to my guns and told her that she had been removed from the show because of her disobedience to my instructions.
What was it Ann Landers used to say? ... No one can take advantage of you without your permission ...? Student-actors will take advantage of teacher-directors if they see that they can do it and get away with it.
------------------------------
Jeff Grove
Theatre Teacher, Aesthetics Department Chair
Stanton College Preparatory School
Jacksonville FL
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 12-02-2018 22:35
From: Arden Thomas
Subject: have you cut an actor for not memorizing lines?
We open The Real Inspector Hound by Tom Stoppard in 9 days, and the Senior playing Birdboot hasn't memorized his lines. Today he was crying to me that he's tried and tried but there doesn't seem to be anything else he can do - the lines aren't sticking. He doesn't see how he can put any more time into it b/c of school work and college apps, but he's trying and he works every evening and it's still not sticking.
Oh, and he wants to miss tech so he can go away for the day with his friends for his 18th birthday. No backing down on that one.
Our off-book deadline but still able to call for lines was Nov 13. He wasn't even close. Totally off book deadline was Nov 20. Again, no progress. On Nov 13th I told him if he wasn't off book the day we returned from Thanksgiving break I was going to have another actor understudy and take over the role. He said that wouldn't have to happen.
I talked to his mom, who promised to help. She said that over Thanksgiving they worked every day. She even hired a tutor to come in and help him. After Thanksgiving, he still didn't have even a single monologue memorized, and certainly not any of the rat-a-tat-tat back and forth lines.
And I didn't cut him and put in the other actor because ... well, I just should have.
Now here we are, 9 days before opening, and I don't know what to do.
The actor I could substitute for him (currently playing Simon) has a nearly photographic memory and has most of Birdboot's lines memorized simply b/c he's been in rehearsal. I'd have to get another actor to play Simon.
Would you cut this actor?
Another option: have him perform script in hand.
I might add that I do not see doing a play in high school simply as a "learning experience." No, I want this to be damn good.
Thank you!
Arden
------------------------------
Arden Thomas
Sequoyah High School
Pasadena CA
------------------------------