Hi Ryan,
I completely agree with you. I've made my share of casting mistakes over the course of my career in theatre, but I had no one to blame but myself. I can't see putting myself in the position of directing someone else's vision of the cast.
From the other side of the issue, I have seen shows over the years where I sat in the audience and wondered why the director chose the particular actor. I didn't think the actor worked in the part. I would have chosen someone different. Of course, I wasn't in the room when the director made the casting choices so I don't know why it ended up that way. Would my choices have been better? Perhaps. Would they have worked for that directors vision? Perhaps, or perhaps not.
I was very clear in my casting standards. I warned the students that every casting director has his / her biases. I even shared with the students some of my casting biases that I was aware of and worked to avoid. (and let them know there might be some of which I was not aware) I was very clear with both students and parents that, while I really appreciated the parent's contributions to the boosters, those contributions would have no impact on casting. I never precast any part for any production. (The handfull of times that I had a specific student in mind for a specific part, it somehow came out that that student never got that part after the auditions.) I have had students both grateful and angry with me. I have had parents both grateful and angry with me. I'm sure many have second guessed me, but I think, ultimately, we all respected each other in the artistic process and understood that the process is subjective no matter who is making the decisions.
------------------------------
Robert Smith
VA Co-Chapter Director
Retired
Centreville VA
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 01-15-2020 07:07
From: Ryan Moore
Subject: Inviting outside professionals to cast your show
I may just be playing devil's advocate here--obviously everyone make choices that are right for their students, their school, and their community, and an important part of teacher self-care is "choosing your battles." But does anyone else have the feeling that bringing in outside "authorities" sends a bad message, as if "confessing" that teachers lack professional judgment. Plus, I always get a little squicky about people being involved in casting that will not be a part of production because, ultimately, the director is the one who's going to have to work with the cast. (I feel this way even about community theatres that I have been associated with that have a casting committee.) I wonder--I honestly don't know--is there a paradigm in the world of athletics where outsiders are brought in for team tryouts? Or is the coach simply seen as the authority? (Then again we all know the nonsense of how sports are seen as more objective somehow and theatre as more subjective.) Tracy, I wish you luck in whatever you choose to do. Just had to exorcise my nagging feeling as I read this thread.
------------------------------
Ryan Moore
Theatre Teacher and Forensics Coach
Royal Oak MI
Original Message:
Sent: 01-11-2020 18:33
From: Tracy Wagner
Subject: Inviting outside professionals to cast your show
After dealing with upset students & parents over the last four years, while dealing with rumors & lies about our selection process, I would like to invite or hire other professionals with no connection to our school to select the cast. Any experience with this way of casting? Pros/Cons?
Any thoughts or suggestions would be appreciated!
Peace,
Ms. Tracy Lynn Wagner
Physical Education Teacher
FPA Dramatic Director & Choreographer
International Thespian Society Troupe #8880 Director
AV Coordinator/ AV Crew Director
Student Council Moderator
Lancaster Catholic High School
650 Juliette Ave.
Lancaster, PA 17601
717-509-0315
717-509-0312 (fax)
Confidentiality Notice:
This message and all attachments transmitted with it are intended solely for the use of the addressee and may contain legally privileged and confidential information. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, or an employee or agent responsible for delivering this message to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, copying or other use of this message or its attachments is strictly prohibited. If you received this message in error, please notify the sender immediately by replying to this message and please delete it from your computer. Thank you.