Your statement that you might be "writing" a musical gives me pause because you then go on to describe using existing songs.
A musical is comprised of a score and libretto.
Permission will never be granted to shoehorn existing songs around a libretto of your own creation --- whether they be pop songs or from various other musicals. UNLESS the songs are in the public domain.
As others suggested: creating your own revue is fine, but there are limitations on that: no book, story line, through line, character/arcs, costumes, sets, etc. A revue (of your own creation) = concert with suggestions of costumes, etc. A licensed revue (as in Tintypes, etc.) may have those dramatic elements because rights were given to an author/director to create them in the original (usually first class --- meaning Broadway or West End) production.
A revue falls under small rights permission (ACAP, BMI, SESAC): once you add dramatic elements (choreo, sets, costumes, etc) then you enter the realm of grand rights and the licensing houses who exclusively rep the author's work.
------------------------------
Michael McDonough
New York NY
Original Message:
Sent: 03-02-2016 19:13
From: Analiese Hamm
Subject: Calling all Musical Experts!
I am about to take on writing my second musical for my troupe. I did it last year because I simply could not find a musical that fit our needs. Everything worked out great, but I'm a little more nervous this time around. My student population is so small, I have to pick the musical based on them rather than audition for any choice musical. And This year I am running extraordinarily low on soloists. I have one fantastic heavyset baritone and one very inexperienced freshman sophomore. That's it. Anyone know of a musical that is primarily ensemble numbers?? I enjoyed writing because I had full control over the musical selections, but if I could just find one that works for us..believe me..I would like to rest a little this spring!
------------------------------
Analiese Hamm
ECHS Drama Director
Lake Park GA
------------------------------