I've done quite a few cutting edge shows with teens. Here are a few of my favorites.
The Wresting Season, by Laurie Brooks. 4 boys, 4 girls (1 adult non-speaking role) simple sets and costumes (literally wrestling mats and singlets. Some hoodies and jackets. The proper wrestling shoes can be a bit costly). This can be a tough show to stage movement wise and hard to cast. You need four boys who can be convincing high school wrestlers (not usually the body types you have in a drama program) but remember, these are high school wrestlers, so they don't need to look like John Cena. The plays covers a variety of issues important to teens, from ethics to gossip, including LGBT hate crimes and date rape. I recommend getting an actual wrestling coach involved to teach the kids some convincing moves. Incredibly rewarding show for your actors and community however.
I also highly recommend columbinus by Stephen Karam and P.J. Paparelli. A docu-drama about high school shootings specifically centered on the shootings in Littleton Colorado in the 90's, but also dealing with the alienation and disconnect that can lead to such violence. Couldn't be more timely. Couldn't be more real. A harrowing play but my students and I were transformed by the experience. 5 boys and 3 girls might be too boy heavy. Strong language. Both plays are available through Dramatic Publishing.
Side note: Steve Karam's Speech and Debate is also a gem of a show. 2 boys, 1 girl, i adult woman. Might be too small a cast for your needs but it's one of the best teen comedies in years. Three high school misfits get involved in a mayoral sex scandal that strangely mirrors the plot of The Crucible and somehow involves a time traveling Abraham Lincoln. Anyone who deals with theater kids will love love LOVE this show.
If you like She Kills Monsters, a show that I'm looking at for next year is Roberto Aquirre-Sacasa's Rough Magic. The play is a fantasy adventure riff on Shakespeare's The Tempest, about a college dramaturg with the magical power to pull literary characters out of dramatic fiction and into the real world. Her powers come in handy when the "real" Prospero, on whom Shakespeare's play is based, decided to unleash his magical fury on Manhattan. Large cast, strong female lead. If you are unfamiliar with Aguirre-Sacasa, he's is a former head writer for Spiderman Comics, Archie Comics and the TV series GLEE. He's also the creator and show-runner for Riverdale on the CW and wrote the book for Broadways' Spiderman, Turn off the Dark. His aesthetic speaks to all of these influences, and other than Qui Ngyun and The Vampire Cowboys, I think he's one of the best writers out there right now for teen audiences. Also check out his horror plays The Weird, The Miracle Plays and Dark Matters.
Hope this helps!
------------------------------
John Monteverde
Drama Teacher
Pittsfield High School
Pittsfield, MA
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 11-07-2017 07:32
From: John Perry
Subject: Need a Play That Is "Cutting Edge"
I'm looking for a play for the Spring. I was planning on Peter and the Starcatcher but I'm just not up to it since this is my last year. In the past we have done Laramie Project, She Kills Monsters, The Frogs, The Birds, Almost, Maine, All In The Timing, Frankenstein. We can do almost anything and I'd like to do a small cast show with lots of good female roles and a play that is a bit "progressive" and 'cutting edge". Easy tech would help, too. Any suggestions?
------------------------------
John Perry
Drama Instructor
Atherton High School
Louisville KY
------------------------------